.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Proviso Probe

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Proviso Township High Schools worst in Illinois in multiple categories

In the most recent school year Proviso Township High Schools (District 209) had the lowest percent of students that meet or exceed standards on standardized tests in the state of Illinois. Results were obtained from the Illinois Interactive Report Card sponsored by Northern Illinois University.

Proviso scores went down absolutely (less students meet or exceed standards) and relative to other districts. Last year Proviso could at least claim to have more students meeting standards than Bloom.

District 209 has the lowest graduation rate in the state. [Orion corrected in comments.]

District 209's dropout rate is tied with Odin (Marion, IL) for #1 in Illinois.

District 209 has the second highest rate of chronic truancy.

District 209 has more low income students than most districts. However, many districts have more low income students. And even in these poorer districts, more students meet or exceed standards.

And District 209 spends more per pupil than most districts.

Who is to blame?

  • The District 209 board of education, especially, board president Emanuel "Chris" Welch
  • The unions
  • The mayors
  • Karen Yarbrough, the Democratic Committeeman
  • Charles Flowers, the former Regional Superintendent of Education
  • Illinois State Board of Education
  • Cook County States Attorney
  • Superintendent Nettie Collins-Hart and her predecessors, especially Robert Libka
  • U.S. Attorney Northern Illinois District
  • board members of Proviso's elementary school districts
  • Gov. Pat Quinn
  • The voters

    In different ways, all these people could have made a difference and improved D209 and the education received by D209 students. And all of these people did too little.

    Flowers might be able to plead that he was simply a fuck-up and didn't really have the ability to make a difference. But let's be honest. When he got elected Regional Superintendent he was more focused on taking care of his people than making a difference in the quality of education received by students.

    Quinn's influence is weak and extends through the Illinois State Board of Education. But I suspect if he lit a fire under the ass of the state superintendent of education, things could be made better.

    Proviso property owners pay taxes for services. They don't like getting ripped-off, but they aren't mad enough about it to take effective action.

1 New Trier 90
2 Northfield 81
3 Elmwood Park 78
4 Lyons 75
5 Riverside-Brookfield 72
6 Township HSD 214 70
7 Lemont 69
8 Oak Park & River Forest 68
9 Con HSD 230 67
10 Maine 66
11 Township HSD 211 66
12 Homewood Flossmoor 63
13 Evanston 62
14 Niles 61
15 Reavis 59
16 Ridgewood 58
17 Evergreen Park 57
18 Oak Lawn 54
19 Bremen 53
20 Leyden 46
21 Argo 44
22 CHSD 218 39
23 Rich 37
24 Thornton Fractional 35
25 Thornton 30
26 Bloom 28
27 Proviso 25

Labels: ,


  • The number after the district is the percent of students that meet or exceed standards.

    By Blogger Carl Nyberg, at 10:02 PM, November 17, 2010  

  • Since Elmwood Park is a consolidated district (elementary and high school), it may be an apples and oranges comparison.

    By Blogger Carl Nyberg, at 10:03 PM, November 17, 2010  

  • Great to see you back!
    I believe that all the local leaders are to blame, since they are using our school and taxpyaers money for jobs for friends,relatives and cronies, and they don,t care one bit if the students learn!Welch,Yarbrough and Flowers are the true cause of the failure and rip off of our education money.

    By Anonymous you got it, at 4:58 AM, November 18, 2010  

  • "District 209 has the lowest graduation rate in the state" Carl, not sure where you got your data for this statement, but the ISBE Report card for 2010 and 2009 lists Proviso West's graduation rate as 100%. And that 100% in 2010 is with a students with disabilities rate of 47%! By the way New Trier does not have a 100% graduation rate for 2010....somehow the graduation rate listed for Proviso West does not seem that it is based on fact. I wonder what other data is just wishful thinking.

    By Anonymous Orion, at 12:47 PM, November 20, 2010  

  • Orion is correct that I am incorrect.

    I misread the graph.

    By Blogger Carl Nyberg, at 9:59 AM, November 21, 2010  

  • When you click through, you can pull down the menu after "Compared by" and compare by different factors.

    By Blogger Carl Nyberg, at 10:01 AM, November 21, 2010  

  • So, the graduation rate according to the ISBE is 96%. That just proves that Proviso is graduating bunches of kids who can't read (26percentile, can't do math (24th percentile) and don't know beans about science (22 percentile). God help us when these kids get out of high school, diploma in hand, and enter the workforce!

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:08 AM, November 27, 2010  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home